The Classic: Remington 1100
For decades, the name Remington has resonated with hunters, target shooters, and firearm enthusiasts alike. The company’s contribution to the world of shotguns is legendary, crafting durable and reliable firearms that have become classics. Two models stand out as particularly iconic: the Remington 1100 and the Remington 1187. Both semi-automatic shotguns have earned legions of fans, but the quest to determine which one is “better” has fueled countless debates. This article dives deep into a comparative analysis of the Remington 1187 and 1100, providing you with the insights you need to choose the ideal shotgun to match your specific needs.
The Remington 1100 represents a landmark achievement in shotgun design. Introduced in the early nineteen-sixties, the 1100 quickly gained popularity, establishing itself as a dominant force in the market. Its reputation for reliable performance and its comfortable recoil characteristics helped cement its status as a true classic. Its sleek lines and dependable operation have made it a favorite for generations.
One of the defining features of the Remington 1100 is its gas-operated action. This innovative design, where gases from the fired cartridge are harnessed to cycle the action, results in a smoother and softer recoil impulse. This makes the 1100 particularly pleasant to shoot, especially for extended periods. Many shooters consider the 1100 a dream to handle.
The 1100’s design includes a variety of barrel options, offering flexibility for different shooting applications. Barrel lengths vary, and different choke configurations are available. The receiver is constructed from durable steel. Its simple elegance and intuitive operation contribute to its timeless appeal.
The Upsides of the Remington 1100
The Remington 1100’s strengths are numerous and well-documented. Its most celebrated characteristic is undoubtedly its remarkably soft recoil. This translates to a more comfortable shooting experience, allowing for faster follow-up shots and reducing shooter fatigue. This is a major advantage, especially for those who spend significant time at the range or in the field.
Reliability, when properly maintained, is another hallmark of the 1100. The gas-operated system, while requiring diligent cleaning, is generally robust and dependable, capable of functioning consistently in various conditions. Many 1100s have been passed down through families, a testament to their longevity and reliability.
Accuracy is also a strong point. The 1100 is generally known to be quite accurate. Its accuracy potential can be further enhanced through careful selection of ammunition and the use of appropriate chokes.
Finally, the 1100’s widespread availability makes it an excellent option. You can often find them on the used market, and the cost is generally affordable.
The Downsides of the Remington 1100
While the Remington 1100 has many advantages, there are a few limitations to consider. First, it requires consistent care and maintenance. The gas system, while effective, needs to be kept clean to function optimally. Buildup of carbon residue can affect performance, and proper lubrication is essential.
The 1100 can sometimes be finicky with certain types of ammunition. Some models, particularly those with original specifications, may struggle to cycle reliably with low-powered loads. Careful selection of ammunition is sometimes necessary to ensure smooth operation.
Furthermore, the standard 1100 is typically chambered for shells up to a certain inch length. While some variants may handle longer shells, this limitation should be considered for those who prefer shooting larger loads.
Given its age, the 1100 generally lacks some of the more modern features found in newer shotgun designs. While its simplicity is part of its charm, shooters seeking advanced features may look elsewhere.
The Evolution: Remington 1187
The Remington 1187 emerged as an evolution of the 1100 design, and its introduction aimed to build upon the successes of its predecessor while addressing some of its shortcomings. Introduced a number of years after the 1100, the 1187 quickly became a popular option. Its design incorporated enhancements and refinements that aimed to make it even more versatile and reliable.
The Remington 1187 maintains a gas-operated action, but it builds upon the 1100’s design with some innovations. The most significant of these is its self-regulating gas system. This system automatically adjusts to accommodate a wider range of shell lengths and power levels. This enhances the 1187’s flexibility and allows it to cycle ammunition more reliably across different loads.
The 1187 is available with a range of barrel configurations, with various lengths and choke options available. The receiver is also made from sturdy materials, and the overall design reflects the familiar Remington aesthetic.
The Positives of the Remington 1187
The Remington 1187 offers several advantages. A key benefit is its ability to handle a broader range of ammunition. The self-regulating gas system makes it well-suited for various shell lengths. This versatility is a major selling point.
The gas system is a significant improvement. The self-regulating system effectively manages the pressure from different loads. This makes the 1187 more reliable.
The 1187 is also relatively easy to clean and maintain. While regular cleaning is still necessary to ensure optimum performance, the 1187 is often considered more forgiving than its predecessor in this regard.
The Negatives of the Remington 1187
While the 1187 is an excellent shotgun, it’s not without its drawbacks. It can be more expensive than a comparable 1100, particularly when purchased new.
While the 1187’s recoil is generally manageable, it might be slightly more noticeable compared to the 1100.
Some shooters find the 1187 is not as smooth or as refined as the 1100, a matter of personal preference.
A Side-by-Side: Comparing the 1100 and 1187
Now, let’s delve into a head-to-head comparison to highlight the differences between these two Remington shotguns.
When we examine the functionality, the 1187 stands out due to its self-regulating gas system. The self-adjusting feature allows it to use a wider variety of loads. The 1100, while reliable, can be less forgiving with different shell types. The 1187 is often easier to adapt to diverse ammunition.
Regarding ammunition compatibility, the 1100 is often best suited for standard length shells. Some exceptions exist, but generally, that is the limitation. The 1187 is more flexible. It will often chamber longer shell lengths. This gives the 1187 an edge in versatility.
The recoil of the 1100 is generally considered lighter and gentler, making it a more pleasant choice for long shooting sessions. The 1187, while still quite manageable, may exhibit slightly more felt recoil.
In terms of maintenance, both require regular cleaning. However, the 1187’s self-regulating system may offer some advantage.
When it comes to accuracy, both models are capable of excellent performance. The shooter’s skill and the choice of ammunition and choke play a significant role.
The cost and availability of these shotguns varies. The 1100 can sometimes be found more affordably on the used market. The 1187 may command a higher price, particularly when purchased new.
In terms of ergonomics, both shotguns are well-designed, but individual preferences vary. Some shooters might find the 1100 slightly more comfortable due to its lighter weight and softer recoil.
Choosing the Right Shotgun
Let’s consider the best shotgun for different kinds of shooters.
If you are primarily a hunter, the choice between the 1100 and 1187 depends on your specific hunting needs. If you need to use a wide range of shell sizes, the 1187 could be a better fit.
For target shooting, both shotguns offer a solid foundation for trap, skeet, and sporting clays. The 1100, with its soft recoil, might be the favored choice for a casual shooter.
When you’re considering a shotgun for home defense (if legal in your area), factors like barrel length and shell choice become extremely important. Consider the maneuverability and stopping power needed.
Making a Decision
In conclusion, the Remington 1100 and 1187 are both exceptionally well-regarded shotguns. The 1100 is often the choice for its soft recoil, its classic design, and affordability, especially on the used market. The 1187 appeals to shooters needing wider shell compatibility. Both are renowned for reliability and accuracy. When making your decision, take a moment to consider your shooting requirements. Your choice should provide decades of enjoyment in the field or on the range.
If you seek a shotgun with a classic pedigree, smooth shooting characteristics, and cost-effectiveness, the 1100 might be your best bet. However, if you require versatility, greater ammunition compatibility, and the latest in gas system technology, the 1187 could be the ideal choice.
Final Thoughts
Both the Remington 1100 and the Remington 1187 are legendary shotguns. Both offer reliability and dependability. No matter which model you choose, you will be joining a community of shooters who appreciate the excellence of Remington shotguns.
When weighing your options, you may find a thriving market of replacement parts and modifications for both models.
Ultimately, the “best” shotgun depends on your individual preferences and how you plan to use it. Carefully assess your shooting needs, evaluate the features of each model, and make an informed decision. You can’t go wrong with either of these time-tested shotguns.
Now, it’s your turn! Share your own experiences with the Remington 1100 and 1187. What are your favorite features of each model? Which one do you prefer and why? We encourage you to discuss this classic competition in the comments below.
